We’re optimizing for one thing: a mat that’s PVC-free with clear materials disclosure. Everything else—grip, odor, durability—comes after the materials story makes sense.
| Category | What we look for | Red flags |
|---|---|---|
| Materials transparency | Exact composition and coatings; clear “PVC-free” statement | “Eco foam”, “proprietary blend”, no composition details |
| Grip | Dry + wet grip, especially for sweat/hot yoga | Only vague claims (“ultra grip”) with no context |
| Odor | Realistic odor guidance; return policy if smell is intolerable | Overpromises (“zero smell”) without caveats |
| Durability | Thickness, wear, peeling, flaking; long-term reviews | Reports of cracking, sticky residue, delamination |
| Care & cleaning | Clear instructions; what to avoid; washable surfaces | No guidance, or advice that conflicts with material reality |
| Policies | Warranty, returns, shipping; customer support | Hard-to-find policies; restrictive returns |
Editorial note: we use affiliate links when available. That does not override the rubric. If a mat has unclear composition, we don’t recommend it.